Saturday, January 10, 2004

Deconstructing the Philanthropic Library: The Sociological Reasons Behind Andrew Carnegie's Millions to Libraries

Deconstructing the Philanthropic Library: The Sociological Reasons Behind Andrew Carnegie's Millions to Libraries This is an excellent essay on Andrew Carnegie by librarian Michael Lorenzen. It is well worth the read.

From the site:

Educational institutions are often founded on and influenced by philanthropy. One of the strongest examples of this is the founding of over two thousand Carnegie Libraries in Europe, the United States, and the English speaking world in the late 19th and early 20th Centuries. Just like other educational institutions, the Carnegie Libraries were influenced heavily by the world around them. The strongest influence came from the source of the money, Andrew Carnegie, who had very strong feelings as to why these libraries were needed including his belief in an America that was a meritocracy and that his libraries would benefit immigrants.


Andrew Carnegie was a Scottish immigrant to the United States in the mid-19th Century. He was poor and was working full-time at the age of twelve. Despite his poor background and the discrimination he faced as an immigrant, he built an industrial empire based on the manufacturing of steel and when he sold his business empire and retired he was worth almost an estimated 400 million dollars. His rags to riches story led him to believe that America was a meritocractic society where anyone who worked hard and smart with a little luck could be successful.

Andrew Carnegie believed strongly in what he called the "Gospel of Wealth." Macleod (1968) summarized this in his book on Carnegie Libraries in Wisconsin. Basically, Carnegie believed that accumulation of wealth by a few was inevitable in any capitalistic society. Further, this concentration of wealth in the hands of a few was necessary for democracy and freedom to prevail and for the whole of society to be prosperous. Any attempt to circumvent this system would lead to anarchy and tyranny. However, Carnegie believed that those who did make it had a moral obligation to give their fortune away before they died to benefit society. In particular, this money was to be spent in a way that did not encourage laziness (charities that only dealt with symptoms and not the problem) but that created institutions that made opportunities for anyone with the right character to be successful and rich.

This philosophy of Carnegie was translated into a wide variety of areas. He gave away $333 million of his fortune on various activities including an attempt to simplify spelling, helping churches, endowing (and in some cases founding) institutions of higher education, and supporting the arts. However, his largest gifts were reserved for libraries. Carnegie gave money to build 2,509 libraries throughout the English speaking world including the British Isles, Australia, and New Zealand. Of these libraries, 1,679 of them were built in the United States and in American possessions that were later incorporated into America proper (Alaska, Hawaii, Puerto Rico, Samoa, and the U.S. Virgin Islands). He spent over $55 million on libraries alone and he is often referred to as the "Patron Saint of Libraries." (Bobinski, 1969)

Thursday, January 08, 2004

American Presidents Blog

American Presidents Blog Blog featuring sites that relate to the American Presidency or specific American Presidents. Created by Michael Lorenzen who is a librarian at Central Michigan University.

This is a nice blog which features different sites on the different American Presidents. It is well done.

Sunday, January 04, 2004

The Corpse in the Cellar: And Further Tales of Cleveland Woe

The Corpse in the Cellar: And Further Tales of Cleveland Woe This is a review of a book on Cleveland, Ohio history by John Stark Bellamy. It is reviewed by Julie Lorenzen.

From the review:

Author John Stark Bellamy II has found his niche: murder and disaster in the Cleveland area. The Corpse in the Cellar completes his trilogy on the subject. His other two books are They Died Crawling and The Maniac in the Bushes. Bellamy's most recent work is a compilation of 25 true stories of mayhem. The stories are antiquated-ranging from a 1865 stalking-style murder to a 1942 circus fire that killed more than 50 animals.

Bellamy has avoided more recent stories for two reasons-summed up by one quote. "… they are too recent, in my opinion, to have acquired a vintage character in terms of the period detail their telling may display; moreover, [more recent stories] are still fresh enough to feature living victims: the sons, daughters, parents and other loved ones who have endured and survived the crimes and disasters of the last 30 years."(Preface)

However, the age of the stories does not make them less interesting. Though morbid, each story has the potential to intrigue readers. For example, there's the story about the teenager who killed a neighbor girl in 1889. He hid her body in the cellar of his mother's house, but was given away by the ensuing odor. And then there was the Ashtabula bridge disaster in which more than 80 train passengers died when a poorly designed bridge collapsed in December 1876.

The first two or three paragraphs of every story are well written enough to draw a reader in. However, each of the stories (most run ten or more pages) are too long to maintain one's interest. In light of the subject matter, shorter stories would have sufficed.